Preview

Civil Aviation High Technologies

Advanced search

FUZZY RISK ASSESSMENT OF AVIATION EVENTS

Abstract

The article presents the technique of fuzzy expert assessment of risk that existed at the time an event occurred. The risk assessment is based on matrix proposed by the Airline Risk Management Solution (ARMS) Group. The matrix allows assessing such risks in the numerical values of the conditional average. The values of the indicators in the cells of the matrix obtained by use of data processing got from aviation insurance.In practice the risk assessment that existed at the time of the event is largely based on expert opinions, however ARMS Group does not offer the method of forming estimates expert group total opinion. Conventional methods of expert estimation and averaging of final grades is difficult due to the exponential nature of changes in risk values recorded in thecells, when considered by columns and by rows of the matrix.The proposed method of risk assessment uses the approach adopted in the formation of membership functions according to expert estimates in the theory of fuzzy sets. Experts are invited to classify each event according to one of the categories of potential damage and the effectiveness of barriers parry (defenses) using all available information. Processing of results is conducted using the method of expert analysis of fuzzy data based on the approach of fuzzy set theory. The seriousness (damage) of the occurrence and effectiveness of the barriers considered as linguistic variables, each of which has four term sets. This approach allows taking into account the opinions of experts and obtaining valid estimates of risk do not necessarily coincided with fixed values of matrix cells.

About the Authors

V. D. Sharov
Moscow State Technical University of Civil Aviation
Russian Federation
Doctor of Technical Science, Full Professor of Chair of Flight and Life Safety


V. V. Vurobyov
Moscow State Technical University of Civil Aviation
Russian Federation
Doctor of Technical Science, Professor, Head of Chair of Flight and Life Safety


References

1. Safety Management. Annex 19 to the Convention on International Civil Aviation. ICAO. 1st ed. 2013.

2. Safety Management Manual. Doc.9859. ICAO. 3rd ed. 2013.

3. ISO/IEC 31010 Risk Management – 2011. Methods of risk assessment.

4. Sharov V.D., Vorobyev V.V. Ogranucheniya po ispolzovaniyu matritsi ICAO pri otsenke riska dlya bezopasnosti poletov [Limitations of ICAO risk matrix application in safety risk assessment]. Civil Aviation High Technologies, 2016, Vol. 9, no. 03, pp. 179–187.

5. Nisula J. Operational Risk Assessment. Next Generation Methodology. 2009 [Electronic resource]. Access Mode: http://www.easa.europa.eu/essi/documents/ (accessed 24.03.2017).

6. The ARMS Methodology for Operational Risk Assessment in Aviation Organisations. 2010 [Electronic resource]. Access Mode: https://essi.easa.europa.eu/documents/Methodology.pdf (accessed 24.03.2017)

7. Orlov A.I. Organizatsionnoe i ekonomicheskoe modelirovanie. Uchebnik [Organizational and economic modeling. A tutorial]. M., MSTU im. N.E. Bauman, 2011, Part 2. Expert evaluation. 486 p.

8. Zubkov B.V., Sharov V.D. Teoriya i praktika opredrleniya riskov v aviapredpriyatiyakh pri razrabotke sistem upravleniya bezopasnostyu poletov [The theory and practice of risk management in aviation enterprises in the development of safety management system]. M., MSTU CA, 2010, 196 p.

9. Shtovba S.D. Proektipovaniye nechetkih sistem sredstvami MATLAB [Design of fuzzy systems by means of MATLAB]. M., Goryachaya Liniya – Telecom, 2007, 288 p.

10. Sharov V.D. Metodologiya upravleniya bezopasnostyu poletov v aviakompanii na osnove znachimyukh pokazatelei riska [Methodology for safety management in airlines based on important risk indicators]. Transport of Russian Federation, 2015, no. 6 (61), pp. 43–46.


Review

For citations:


Sharov V.D., Vurobyov V.V. FUZZY RISK ASSESSMENT OF AVIATION EVENTS. Civil Aviation High Technologies. 2017;20(3):6-12. (In Russ.)

Views: 719


Creative Commons License
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 License.


ISSN 2079-0619 (Print)
ISSN 2542-0119 (Online)