METHOD OF THE ADEQUACY ASSESSING OF SIMULATION IN RADIO ELECTRONIC MEANS OPERATORS TRAINING FACILITY ON THE BASIS OF THE FLIGHT EXPERIMENT

The research determines the problems of pilot studies to assess the adequacy of the results of simulation in simulators operators of radio electronic equipment for air traffic control. Hardware requirements to conduct flight experiments to assess the adequacy of training facilities by members of the flight management group for air traffic control in the near field zone are formulated. For the probabilistic assessment of simulation adequacy in training facility radio electronic means (REM) operators the generalized criterion "Fisher - Chi-square" is selected, which allows to obtain the updated value of the significance level using the Fisher criterion, and based on this, using the goodness of fit Chi-square to produce a quantitative assessment of the adequacy of the simulation in the training facility radio electronic equipment. In order to improve the quality of training of the trainees (members of the flight management group) and a greater degree of approximation of processes that are modeled in training facilities at the ATC in the near field zone to the real conditions, the research proposes a method to evaluate the adequacy of the simulation results in training equipment operators REM ATC on the basis of the flight experiment. It is shown that when implemented on the basis of the flight experiment of the proposed method of assessing the adequacy of the equipment operators REM ATC, the reliable values of accuracy can be obtained simultaneously for ground and in-flight tracking of air objects that are used in their simulation models in training facilities for the traffic controllers training procedures. Experimental assessment of the air traffic control equipment operators adequacy allows the authors to come to the conclusion that the results obtained on the basis of the Fisher-χ2 and on the basis of the generalized distribution law can be used to form areas of implementation of means of conflict-resistant automated control system for RES operators training management.

1. Potapov A.N., Pasmurnov S.M. Matematicheskaya model’ kolichestvennogo kriteria otsenki adekvatnosti imitatsionnogo modelirovania v trenajorah operatorov ergotehnicheskih sistem [Mathematical model of quantitative criterion of the estimation of adequacy of the simulation modeling in training apparatus of operators of energotehnichesky systems]. Vestnik Voronezhskogo gosudarstvennogo universiteta [Bulletin of Voronezh State Technical University], 2012, Vol. 8, № 3, pp. 4–8. (in Russian)

2. Potapov A.N. Optimizatsia trenajornoy podgotovki operatorov slozhnih informatsionnyh radioelektronnih sistem upravlenia vozdushnim dvizheniem [Optimization of simulator training operators of complex information radio electronic systems of air traffic control]. Materialy 11 mezhdunarodnoy nauchno-metodicheskoy konferentsii “Informatika: problemy, metodologiya tehnologii” [Proceedings of the 11thInternational scientific and methodological conference «Informatics: problems, methodology, technology»], Vol. 2. Voronezh, VSU, 2011, pp. 216–222. (in Russian)

3. Potapov A.N., Moiseev S.N. Matematicheskaya model’ processa issledovaniy tochnostnih harakteristik radiolokatsionnyh sistem soprovozhdenia vozdushnih tseley [Mathematical model of the research process of accurate characteristics of aerial targets support’s radiolocation systems]. Vestnik Kazanskogo tehnicheskogo univresiteta [Bulletin of the Kazan Technological University], 2013, Vol. 16, № 23, pp. 235–241. (in Russian)

4. Kleinman D.L. On an Iterative Technique for Riccati Equation Computation // IEEE Trans. On Automatic Control, 2008, Vol. 13, № 1, pp. 20–25.

5. Lambert M. Training the Ariline Pilot. M. Lambert, R. Lopez. Interavia, 1982, № 12, p. 127.

6. Grewall M., Weill L.R., Andrews A.P. Global Navigation Satellite Systems, Inertial Navigation, and Integration. N.Y., John Wiley & Sons, Third Edition, 2013, 608 p.

7. Potapov A.N., Ovcharov V.V. Otsenka adekvatnosti imitatsionnogo modelirovania v informatsionnyh avtomatizirovannyh sistemah osvoenia ergotehnicheskih kompleksov, imeyushih ierarhicheskuyu strukturu postroenia [Assessment of the adequacy of the simulation in simulators ergotehnicheskih operators with hierarchical structure of building]. Vestnik Voronezhskogo gosudarstvennogog tehnicheskogo universiteta [Bulletin of the Voronezh State Technical University], 2013, Vol. 9, №. 3-1, pp. 45–48. (in Russian)

8. Potapov A.N., Bunin A.V. Sistemnaya model’ formirovania konfliktno-ustoychivih operatsiy upravlenia ergotehnicheskimi radiolokatsionnymi sredstvemi [Systemic Model of Formation Conflict-Sustainable Management Operations Ergotechnical Radio-Electronic Means]. Zhurnal Sibirskogo federalnogo universiteta. Seria “Tehnika i tehnologii” [Journal of Siberian Federal University. Series "engineering and technologies"], 2016, Vol. 9, No. 8, pp. 1207–1216. (in Russian)

9. Potapov A.N. Otsenka adekvatnosti imitasionnogo modelirovania v trenazhorah operatorov informatsionnyh ergotehnicheskih sistem, imeyushih ierarhicheskuyu strukturu postroyenia [Assessing the adequacy of simulation modeling in training equipment operators of ergo technical information systems with hierarchical structure]. Proceedings of the 13th International scientific and methodological conference "Informatics: problems, methodology, technologies". February 7-8th, 2013, Vol. 3, Voronezh, VSU, 2013, 480 p. (in Russian)

10. Powell David E. Modular Aircrew Simulation Systems. David E. Powell, James W. Dille. AIAA Flidht Simul. Tech. Conf and Exhib, 1989, pp. 237–242.

11. The certificate of the official registration of a computer program 2013610592 of the Russian Federation. The system of operative objective control of operators’ actions of air traffic control information systems. / A.N. Potapov, E.S. Sysoev (RU). Application 2012619942, 19.11.2012; reg. in the registry of computer programs of Rospatent 09.01.2013. 1 p.